Contact Us for a Free Consultation 717-202-2277


PFA and Assault In Pennsylvania

Posted by Sean Quinlan | May 24, 2021 | 0 Comments

Domestic violence is a serious problem in our country and one that should be aggressively addressed. People can be falsely accused, however, resulting in harsh consequences that can change lives forever. If you have been charged with assault or are facing a restraining order brought against you by a person you are alleged to have assaulted, you need to understand exactly what you're up against.

Assault in Pennsylvania

Under Pennsylvania Law, there are two basic charges you could face for assault in Cumberland County: simple assault and aggravated assault. Generally speaking, simple assault is a misdemeanor of the first, second or third degree with the possibility of up to five years in jail and a maximum fine of $10,000, if you are convicted.

Aggravated assault is a much more serious charge and is a felony offense in Cumberland County. Aggravated assault charges can range from first to third degree felonies, and a conviction means a prison sentence of up to 20 years, as well as up to $25,000 in fines.

Whether you are facing a simple assault charge or an aggravated assault charge, it's important to understand that you can be convicted even if you didn't actually harm or intend to harm the alleged victim. The authorities can charge you with assault in the following situations:

  • You attempted to cause harm to someone.
  • You put someone in fear of imminent bodily injury.
  • You negligently or recklessly injured another person.

Assault charges can cover a wide variety of actions and many people are shocked when they learn that they are being charged with assault.

How Assault Charges and Restraining Orders Are Related

Domestic disputes often result in allegations of abuse and may lead to a charge of simple assault or aggravated assault.

PFA Assault
In addition to the abuse allegation, the alleged victim may then pursue a restraining order.

A restraining order or ‘Protection From Abuse Order' is a legal decree that prohibits one person from having contact with another person. It typically prohibits someone from coming within a certain distance of the alleged victim. Additionally, the order can also prohibit any contact with the victim whatsoever, either directly or through an intermediary (other than the police or the court). A restraining order can also contain other restrictive provisions, including requiring the accused to move out of his or her home, as well as dictating how and when the accused can see his or her children.

Domestic violence includes a broader spectrum of relationships than just husband and wife. In Pennsylvania, it is possible for the following people to seek a restraining order against you:

  • A spouse or former spouse
  • A current or former member of your household
  • Someone you have dated or are currently dating
  • Someone with whom you have a child

Needless to say, a restraining order could seriously impact your day-to-day life. If you're facing a PFA order, speak with a Cumberland County restraining order lawyer as soon as possible.

Two Separate Legal Proceedings

If you are charged with assault and the alleged victim is seeking a restraining order, it is important to understand that the assault charge and the restraining order will be handled by two independent legal processes. This means that you have to defend yourself in both proceedings, held in separate courts with different judges.

Do not assume that the restraining order will be resolved if you prevail in your criminal case, or vice versa. Both actions will require a separate defense.

Understanding the PFA Process

Once you are charged with assault in a criminal case, you could follow two basic courses of action: (1) attempt to resolve the case by entering into a plea agreement with the prosecutor, or (2) proceed to trial where the prosecutor will have to prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

The restraining order process is quite different. Here is a broad overview of how the restraining order process works:

  1. Your accuser fills out the appropriate forms and files them with the court. It will be given to a judge for review. If requested, and if the judge believes that your accuser is in immediate danger, a temporary protection from abuse order (TPFA) will be entered which will go into effect immediately.
  2. The police will serve you with a copy of the TPFA and seize any and all firearms in your possession. You will be required to comply with TPFA's terms immediately.
  3. A hearing will be scheduled to take place within 10 days of the date that the TPFA was issued.
  4. The hearing will determine whether or not a final restraining order (PFA) is appropriate. You will have the opportunity to attend the hearing to hear the evidence against you and defend yourself.

The restraining order process differs from a criminal proceeding in a few significant ways:

  • If the judge enters a PFA, that PFA will remain in effect for as long as the court says it does. It does not go away if you reconcile with your accuser. You must file a petition with the court requesting that the PFA be rescinded or modified.
  • Your accuser does not need to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt.
  • Your case will be decided by a judge, not a jury.

Why You Need a Lawyer for Both

An aggravated assault charge is serious – you are potentially facing years in prison and thousands of dollars in fines if convicted. While the consequences of a restraining order may not be as serious, it could drastically change your life. You may be prohibited from going places you typically frequent, you may have to move, or your ability to see your children may be severely restricted. If a PFA is entered, you will also be prevented from legally owning a firearm in the state of Pennsylvania.

You will suffer serious consequences if you neglect either of these cases. Unfortunately, both proceedings are complex and confusing for those not familiar with the laws surrounding them. A simple misstep can jeopardize your case and ultimately your rights. If you've been charged with assault and are facing a restraining order, you need a criminal defense attorney who understands the significance of both proceedings and can defend you in each one.

Contact a Cumberland County Assault and PFA Attorney

If you've been charged with assault and are facing a PFA, your life and your future are at stake. Don't face these challenges alone – talk to a Cumberland County criminal defense lawyer who will fight for your rights and get you a fair result. Pennsylvania criminal defense attorney Sean Quinlan has experience fighting assault charges in both criminal court and restraining order hearings. For a free consultation, call us at 717 202-2277 to discuss your case and how we can help. Call us at 717 202-2277 to schedule a free consultation today.

About the Author

Sean Quinlan

Attorney Quinlan has practiced law in Pennsylvania since 2001. He earned his J.D. at Widener University School of Law in Harrisburg, PA, and earned his B.A. at Bloomsburg University in Bloomsburg, PA. He is a member of the Pennsylvania Bar. He also belongs to the Pennsylvania State Bar Associati...


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Contact Us Today

Quinlan Law Group, LLC is committed to answering your questions about DUI and Criminal Defense law issues in Dauphin County, Cumberland County and York County, PA.

We'll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.